Is taste a 'new core skill'? Techies debate — and quickly get memed

In recent days, a lively discussion about the value of 'taste' has emerged on social media, highlighting its potential significance in the evolving landscape of artificial intelligence. This conversation was ignited by Paul Graham, co-founder of Y Combinator, who argued that in a world where anyone can create anything, the ability to discern what is worth making becomes a crucial differentiator. Graham's assertion struck a chord, drawing attention to his previous writings on the subject, including a 2002 essay titled 'Taste for Makers.' He emphasized that as technology continues to democratize creation, the judgment behind those creations—referred to as 'taste'—could become a vital skill. OpenAI's president, Greg Brockman, echoed this sentiment, claiming that taste is emerging as a new core competency. This perspective found support among various tech leaders, who acknowledged that as engineers take on more complex roles, strong judgment skills will be essential. Not everyone is convinced, however. Some industry experts argue that AI may surpass human capabilities in this area. For instance, Nan Yuwrote, head of product at Linear, expressed skepticism, suggesting that it may be unlikely for humans to possess better taste than AI. Similarly, Matt Schumer, author of a widely discussed essay on AI, suggested that the notion of taste being a uniquely human trait is questionable, especially as AI continues to learn and adapt. High-profile figures like Rick Rubin, co-founder of Def Jam, also entered the conversation, emphasizing that while he may lack technical skills, his confidence in his own taste is what defines his success. This has led to humorous memes circulating online, poking fun at the evolving role of engineers in the industry and their perceived lack of taste in personal style. As this debate unfolds, it raises intriguing questions about the nature of taste, who possesses it, and how it will be valued in a future dominated by AI. While some see taste as an essential skill for navigating the complexities of technology, others believe that the definition of taste itself remains elusive and subjective. The discourse continues to generate both serious reflections and lighthearted memes, showcasing a blend of passion and humor within the tech community.